Spanish-style homes are a rare architectural gem in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania—a city better known for its brick Tudors and classic Pittsburgh boxes. Yet, tucked into several distinctive neighborhoods, you’ll find beautiful examples of Mediterranean revival and Spanish Colonial Revival homes, complete with stucco exteriors, arched windows, wrought iron accents, and of course, those iconic tile-style roofs.
However, the original clay tiles that often accompany Spanish architecture don’t always suit Pittsburgh’s freeze-thaw climate. That’s why many homeowners in neighborhoods like Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, and Highland Park have opted for a more practical solution: asphalt shingles designed to mimic clay tile. In this post, we’ll explore why replacing shingle roofs on Spanish-style homes makes sense in Pittsburgh, and what to consider during the process.
Spanish-Style Homes in Pittsburgh Neighborhoods
While not abundant, Spanish-style homes are scattered throughout some of Pittsburgh’s most charming and historic neighborhoods. Squirrel Hill is home to several of these homes, particularly in the Murdoch Farms and Beechwood Boulevard areas, where the Mediterranean influence lends a warm, Old World aesthetic to tree-lined streets.
In Shadyside, another historic neighborhood known for its eclectic architecture, you’ll find Spanish-style homes subtly integrated among more traditional Victorian and Queen Anne houses. Their red tile-style roofs stand out against the skyline, making a strong case for architectural diversity in the city.
Over in Highland Park, which borders the large and leafy park of the same name, Spanish Revival homes add an elegant flair to streets filled with early 20th-century constructions. These neighborhoods—Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, and Highland Park—collectively represent some of the most picturesque and sought-after areas in Pittsburgh for lovers of classic design.
Why Shingles Work for Spanish-Style Homes in Pittsburgh
Clay tile roofing, while authentic, can be problematic in Pittsburgh’s climate. The region experiences harsh winters, heavy snow loads, and frequent freeze-thaw cycles. Traditional clay or terracotta tiles are prone to cracking under these conditions. Not only are repairs costly, but replacement tiles can be hard to match, especially for historic homes.
This is where architectural asphalt shingles or composite shingles designed to look like clay tile come into play. Here’s why they work well:
- Durability in Cold Weather: Unlike traditional tile, modern asphalt shingles are engineered to resist cracking and moisture absorption, two major concerns in Pittsburgh’s climate.
- Cost-Effective: Shingles are significantly cheaper than authentic clay tiles and are easier and quicker to install or replace.
- Lightweight: Clay tiles are heavy and may require structural reinforcement. Shingles eliminate that need, which is a major advantage for older Spanish-style homes in neighborhoods like Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, and Highland Park.
- Aesthetic Flexibility: High-quality shingles can replicate the look of curved or flat clay tiles with surprising authenticity. This helps homeowners preserve the Spanish character of their homes without sacrificing performance.
Choosing the Right Contractor
If you’re planning to replace the shingles on a Spanish-style home, it’s crucial to find a roofing contractor experienced with architectural preservation. Rooflines on Spanish-style homes often have complex curves, parapets, or overhangs that require a specialized touch. Contractors familiar with the housing stock in Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, and Highland Park will be best equipped to handle these details without compromising the home’s historic charm.
Final Thoughts
Replacing a roof on a Spanish-style home in Pittsburgh isn’t just about protection from the elements—it’s about preserving beauty while embracing practicality. Architectural shingles provide a smart, visually appealing solution that respects the style’s essence without inviting the risks that come with traditional tile in a harsh northern climate.
If you’re lucky enough to own one of these elegant homes in Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, or Highland Park, consider shingle roofing as your next investment. It’s a modern update with timeless appeal—perfectly suited for Pittsburgh living.
